HEARTBREAK HOUSE – REVIEW OF 2026 SHAW FESTIVAL PRODUCTION

Reviewed by James Karas

George Bernard Shaw has a theatre festival named after him in Niagara-on-the-Lake that has been around since 1962 but its name may be misleading. This year only one of his plays, Heartbreak House, is being produced and in the small Jackie Maxwell Studio Theatre at that. In other words, the Shaw Festival has almost nothing to do with Bernard Shaw.

Directed by Artistic Director Tin Carroll with a superb cast, Heartbreak House gets a decent production once you get past some of his gimmicks. The production is done on the empty playing area of the Studio Theatre and the only props are half a dozen ordinary chairs.

Shaw gives detailed directions about the set in the play and wrote an entire essay on the world of Heartbreak House in his Preface, in other words England before World War I. We are left without a map and Carroll has added lines for the Maid (Kristi Frank) and the Butler (Michael Therriault) who introduce some scenes and characters. They were amusing, but not a part of Shaw’s play.

Did Carroll assess that Heartbreak House would not fill the Festival Theatre? Get another play or wait for the Royal George Theatre to be built.  Do not cheapen Shaw even if it brings a few laughs.

Heartbreak House  has a convoluted plot that presents in modern terms at least, the life of a seriously dysfunctional family and an image of Britain’s upper class before World War I. Shaw’s verbosity is unavoidable but his humour and incisive observations are always there. Tom Rooney plays the eccentric, curmudgeonly naval officer Captain Shotover.  He walks on and off the stage for no reason, he cannot remember his daughter and he has difficulty dealing with people but he is capable of astute observations. Is he  suffering from dementia? The superb Rooney shuffles across the stage in the first act but he finds his bearing and officer’s uniform in the latter part of the play when he appears to be about to marry the young, astute and intelligent Ellie Dunn. 

Sochi Fried, Martin Happer, Tom Rooney, Neil Barclay, Julia Course, 
Graeme Somerville and Jason Cadieux in Heartbreak House. 
Photo by David Cooper.

Allison Edwards-Crewe plays the young, intelligent, clear-headed Ellie Dunn in a fine performance. She has no private fortune and must choose a husband. She is engaged to the arch-capitalist Boss Mangan (Graeme Somerville), she falls in love with Hector (Martin Happer) and how about Captain Shotover?

The Captain’s daughters are a pleasure to the eye thanks to Costume Designer Ximena Pinilla. White gowns in the first half and black hues in the second convey aristocracy with more than shades of decadence. Julia Course as Hesione and Sochi Fried as Ariadne are superb as creatures to the manor born for whom the outside world does not exist.

Neil Barclay plays Ellie Dunn’s father, the pathetic Mazzini who was Mangan’s former partner and was duped by him. Sanjay Talwar plays the brilliant Burglar who breaks into the aristocratic house and convinces the people not to call the police and in fact make a collection for him. Funny and wonderful performance by Talwar.    

Martin Happer as the useless would-be Lawrence of Arabia, Fiona Byrne as the smart and likeable Nurse Guinness and Jason Cadieux as Randall round off the cast of fine performers that make the production more than decent despite Carroll’s gimmicks and unacceptable approach to the play.   

­­­­­_____________

HEARTBREAK HOUSE  by Bernard Shaw will run in repertory until October 3, 2026, at the Jackie Maxwell Studio Theatre as part of the Shaw Festival in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario.  www.shawfest.com.

James Karas is the Cultre Editor of The Greek Press, Toronto