Wednesday, March 18, 2026

A MIRROR - REVIEW OF 2026 ARC PRODUCTION AT 918 BATHURST THEATRE

Reviewed by James Karas 

When you walked into 918 Bathurst St. Toronto to see Sam Holcroft’s play A Mirror, you are given a nicely printed white card stating, “Welcome TO THE WEDDING OF LEYLA AND JOEL.” Leyla (Jonelle Gunderson), the bride, walks down the aisle solemnly and joins the groom Joel (Paul Smith). The Registrar (Nabil Traboulsi) begins the wedding ceremony and the bride and groom exchange vows and we read THE OATH OF ALLEGIANCE written on the back of the Welcome card. It is not exactly a familiar wedding but we take it for what it is.

The Best Man (Craig Lauzon) interrupts the proceeding to announce that this is a sham wedding and is in fact the performance of a play without a license. He invites people who feel uncomfortable to leave the theatre. One person does.

To quote Dorothy, we are certainly not in Kansas or any part of the civilized world. The Oath of Allegiance makes it clear that we are in a totalitarian police state. The transition away from Kansas is sudden and without explanation but then we get to the beginning of the play.

The bride becomes Mei, a  diffident secretary in the ministry of culture. The groom becomes Adem Nariman, an aspiring playwright who has submitted a play to Celik (Traboulsi) for approval and production. The wedding party has become the office of a totalitarian police state. We have a transition from the sham wedding to the office  of Celik in the ministry of culture. What happened to the actors who were putting on an unlicensed play? What play were they putting on?  

Celik in the same three-piece suit and black gloves that he wore as the wedding Registrar has turned into an officious and frightful commissar. Adem has been hauled in for a play that he has submitted for approval not for performing anything. And Mei works for the ministry. This is confusing.

Jonelle Gunderson, Nabil Traboulsi and Paul Smith, 
Photo: Kendra Epik - ARC

Celik as the tough censor has a lot to say to Adem about what he considers as appropriate for the stage and wants him to write something optimistic and not something depressing. The state does not want people to be exposed to certain things.

Adem is defending his writing as realistic and objects to Celik’s censorship. The playwright is a brave cog in the bureaucratic wheel but he is put under pressure to comply and compromise in order to survive.

Holcroft deals with the repressive state with dramatic effects and director Tamara Vuckovic and the cast bring out the horrors and abuses of totalitarianism. At times it feels heavy-handed, familiar and perhaps repetitive but it is all there.

Vuckovic tries to be helpful with the following comments in the program:

What’s so gripping about Sam Holcroft’s A Mirror is its architecture. The

mirrored structure isn’t a stylistic flourish—it is the engine of the play.

Scenes return, reframed, and suddenly what we thought we understood

begins to shift beneath our feet. Instead of inviting the audience to watch

a story about perception—they experience their own perceptions being

challenged in real time. Questions of censorship, authorship, identity, and

the fragile boundary between fiction and reality are embedded directly in

how the story unfolds.

What I thought I understood may have shifted beneath my feet but I probably did not understand in the first place. I did not feel my perception challenged and the boundary between fiction and reality seemed all too real to be considered fragile.

A Mirror was presented at 918 Bathurst St. Toronto which looks like a former church that has  been converted into a performing arts center. There is a raised platform which may have been an altar or a pulpit but serves just as well as a stage. The set by Nick Blais features sheaths of flowing white curtain material with a few chairs and other furniture the emphasis being on white.

I should add that near the end someone appears to remove Celik. He is a Celik look-alike but there is insufficient explanation to diffuse the confusion created in the two hours’ duration of A Mirror. A disappointment.
__________________
A Mirror  by Sam Holdcroft in a production by ARC will run until March 28, 2026, at 918 Bathurst, 918 Bathurst St. Toronto Ontario. arcstage.com

James Karas is the Culture Editor of The Greek Press, Toronto

No comments:

Post a Comment