Wednesday, April 4, 2018

AN AMERICAN IN PARIS – REVIEW OF STAGE VERSION OF GERSHWIN MUSICAL


Reviewed by James Karas

An American in Paris has such unbeatable, indeed aristocratic, provenance that it attracts attention, imitation and adaptation. With music by George Gershwin and lyrics by Ira Gershwin its position in the American musical pantheon is assured of a prime position. The 1951 musical with Genre Kelly and Leslie Caron directed by Vincent Minnelli is one of the best films in the genre.

The film has been adapted for the stage by Craig Lucas who was “Inspired by the Motion Picture,” according to the program and the musical has reached Toronto in the hands of a touring company.

It goes without saying that the Gershwins are the stars. “An American in Paris” is a brilliant concert piece that is used for the long ballet sequence. “I got rhythm,”  “’S Wonderful” and “shall we dance” are familiar and beautiful songs that are a pleasure to hear. In short, you will get some superb ballet sequences, some decent singing, some moronic comedy and Broadway glitz that add up to a highly entertaining night at the theatre.
 
                                  An American in Paris Touring Company. Photo by Matthew Murphy.
Jerry Mulligan (McGee Maddox) is an American soldier in Paris at the end of World War II. He tears up his return ticket to the U.S. and decides to stay in Paris to pursue his passion for painting. He sees a beautiful and mysterious woman and falls in love with her. Sure. Enough suspense. Her name is Lise (Allison Walsh) and she is a budding ballerina.

He meets Adam Hochberg (Matthew Scott), an American musician who was wounded in the war and he will be useful for some comic relief. He describes himself as Oscar Levant who, for those old enough to remember him, was in fact a concert pianist, composer and colourful personality and played Adam in the movie.

We need a third man to get some symmetry in the love triangles and Henri (Ben Michael) fits the role. He is the son of the wealthy Monsieur Baurel (Scott Willis) and Madame Baurel (Teri Hansen) and he has a secret ambition to become a nightclub entertainer.

The woman who will fascinate the men is Lise and she is beautiful, poor, exceptionally talented and has a high moral obligation to marry Henri. Stay tuned because there is a touching story to be told.

The main cast is rounded off by Milo Davenport (Kirsten Scott), rich, blonde American who gets involved in the lives of the aforementioned.

McGee Maddox is a superb dancer and you wait for the ballet sequences. His athletic coordination and bravura dancing from beginning to end are worth the price of admission alone.  Simply marvellous. He is not too bad as a lover and somewhere in the same category as a singer. You can’t have everything but he does have a lot.
 
                                      McGee Maddox and Allison Walsh. Photo by Matthew Murphy.
Allison Walsh meets him step by step in their ballet sequences and she is good vocally as well. Kirsten Scott’s Milo is a classic in the genre of the rich and beautiful who almost get the prize hero. She manages some fine cadenzas and gets high marks for her overall performance.   

Craig Lucas’s book goes quite well until the beginning of the second act when the writing drops to silly sitcom comedy that provides few laughs. But the story eventually finds its rhythm and the dancing propels it to heights of absolute delight.

The set by Bob Crowley shows realistic and abstract views of Paris and a kaleidoscope of brilliant colours. The costumes are impressive and you are left with an overall dazzling show. 
      
Director Christopher Wheeldon keeps up a balanced pace that ranges from the frenetic to the dramatic, to the romantic and in the end all is well and a bit of escapism comes to a rousing conclusion.
__________
An American in Paris by George Gershwin (music), Ira Gershwin (lyrics) and Craig Lucas (book) opened on March 29, and will play until April 29, 2018 at the Princess of Wales Theatre, 300 King St. West, Toronto, Ontario. www.mirvish.com/  416 872 1212

Monday, April 2, 2018

ANIMAL FARM – REVIEW OF SOULPEPPER’S PRODUCTION OF ORWELL’S FABLE


Reviewed by James Karas

I have a prejudice against the adaptation of novels into stage plays. There is a world of difference between the two and I feel that adapting a successful work of fiction for the stage shows a failure of imagination or ability on the part of a writer. If you want a play, write a play. There are successful transfers from novel to stage but my prejudice remains.

The current adaptation of George Orwell’s 1945 novella Animal Farm for the stage by Anthony MacMahon for Soulpepper did nothing to mitigate my prejudice. Director Ravi Jain and Set and Costume Designer Ken MacKenzie dressed up the cast in various costumes to represent the animals of the story and made brave attempts at humour and drama but many of the efforts fell flat.
 
 Animal Farm ensemble, photo by Cylla von Tiedemann

Animal Farm is a fable that indicts and satirizes the Russian Revolution and the communist takeover of Russia by the Bolsheviks. Communism is one of the greatest crimes and frauds perpetrated against humanity but there are still people who support it despite overwhelming evidence of the evil it has meted on humankind.

Eleven actors take on twenty four roles under the direction of Jain in Soulpepper’s presentation of the takeover of Mr. Jones’s farm by the animals in clear parallel with facts of Russian history from Lenin to the brutalities of Stalin.

The actors wear ears, snouts, masks and other paraphernalia to indicate the numerous farm animals of Anima Farm. There is a great deal of effort dedicated to changing the voices of the animals. The horses have low voices, the chickens cackle and most of the voices seem to have an echo or reverberation. After a while I found the sound less than attractive and would have preferred to have the actors do their job rather than have artificial changes to their voices that proved unhelpful.

As a result the satire on the abuse of the animals by the pig called Napoleon (Rick Roberts), who becomes the party leader, the lies and the propaganda are reduced to caricature that is neither funny nor effective. Laughter is scarce and muted when we should be able to get at least a few hearty guffaws. The suffering of the animals, especially of the faithful horse Boxer (Oliver Dennis) should be very moving but the production reduces that part to the point where it is neither human nor animal.
 Oliver Dennis and Guillermo Verdecchia, photo by Cylla von Tiedemann
Squealer (Miriam Fernandes) is the ultimate propaganda machine who lies with complete conviction and for whom facts mean nothing. Benjamin (Guillermo Verdecchia) retains his judgment and sees the corruption of the leaders and the fate of the other animals with clarity.

In the 2 hours and 15 minutes running time of the performance, including a 15 minute intermission, you could read the book and get much more out of it than you do from this production. But all of that may just be my prejudice.     
____________
Animal Farm by George Orwell, adapted by Anthony MacMahon continues at the Young Centre for the Performing Arts, 55 Tank House Lane, Toronto, Ontario. www.soulpepper.ca.

Saturday, March 31, 2018

LES MISERABLES - REVIEW OF THEATRE SMITH-GILMOUR PRODUCTION

James Karas

Michele Smith and Dean Gilmour are the dynamic duo who created Theatre Smith-Gilmour in 1980. In some 40 productions since then, they have proven to be ambitious, inventive, enterprising and just plain bloody good. If they have any competition in longevity and creativity, I am not aware of it.

This year they have taken a huge bite – Victor Hugo’s massive Les Misérables - and offered a series of dramatic scenes from the novel. Even though a large swath of the novel is taken up by essays on various subject, the idea of presenting the main plot thread involving the hero Jean Valjean is simply breathtaking. To give you an idea of the size of the novel, I have an old edition that runs to four volumes.
Smith and Gilmour have six actors represent some 29 characters. The action takes place on a bare stage with a few props and some video projections. Much of the action is mimed and the play does achieve some very dramatic moments. But it also contains an inordinate amount of Dickensian melodrama and sentimentality, and numerous coincidences without Dickens’ humour.

The action is launched with Gilmour as Valjean telling us about his arrest and conviction for stealing a loaf of bread from a bakery in order to stave off gnawing hunger. Gilmour does impressive acting and miming of events in Valjean’s life. He is sent to prison for five years to serve in a galley. His sentence is increased to 19 years for his attempts at escape and the story continues.

On his release Valjean is mistreated because he carries the yellow passport of a convict but he finds shelter and food in the house of a bishop. He steals silver from the bishop, is caught and the bishop pretends that he gave the silver to him. We have met generosity and nobility.

We meet the beautiful Fantine (Nina Gilmour) who has an illegitimate child and has an extremely difficult time surviving. She gives her child to the evil Thenardier couple (Daniel Roberts and Diana Tso) who extract money from her. After some melodramatic scenes, she dies and we will have her daughter Cossette (played by Nina Gilmour) for the rest of the play.
One of the main plot threads is the vengeful pursuit of Valjean by the relentless and merciless Inspector Javert (Mac Fyfe). The other pursuit is by Marius (Benjamin Muir) of Cossette. He is a caricature of the obsessed romantic lover who runs into more obstacles than a steeplechase.

The personal histories are intertwined with national events including war and revolution as Hugo covered a large portion of history and Gilmour and Smith attempt to do justice to the novel. I think they try to chew much more than is possible even in two hours and forty minutes.

Marius’s pursuit of Cossette becomes tiresome because there is overstated ardour without humour. Scenes that may be dramatic become simply sentimental, almost mawkish, and in the end your interest in Valjean’s fate is seriously diminished. When Valjean is given another chance to exterminate the creepy Inspector Javert and he decides to be merciful, I felt like screaming “Blow the bastard’s head off.”    

The six actors’ ability to take on numerous roles is admirable and I don’t want to take anything away Michele Smith’s deft directing and the couple’s brave attempt to give us their stage presentation of a small part of a massive novel.  In the end it is a noble attempt at an impossible task that has some redeeming features but also some big potholes.
___

Les Misérables by Victor Hugo adapted by Michele Smith and Dean Gilmour continues until April 1, 2018 at The Theatre Centre, 1115 Queen St. West, Toronto, Ontario. http://theatresmithgilmour.com/ or www.theatrecentre.org

Friday, March 30, 2018

WHAT A YOUNG WIFE OUGHT TO KNOW - REVIEW OF MOSCOVITCH’S PLAY AT CROW’S THEATRE


James Karas

What a Young Wife Ought to Know, the title of Hannah Moscovitch’s play, is not posed as a question but as a statement or perhaps a wish. If the question were what a young working class wife knew about sex, love, pregnancy and birth control about one hundred years ago, the answer is simple: almost nothing.

Moscovitch tells the story of Sophie (Lisa Repo-Martell), her husband Johnnie (David Patrick Flemming) and her sister Alma (Rebecca Parent) who live in the back water city of Ottawa. They have committed the crime of being born poor and therefore uneducated and therefore condemned to work in jobs that frequently do not pay even subsistence wages.
Lisa Repo-Martell and David Patrick Flemming, Photo: Timothy Richard
Sophie addresses the audience directly, husbands and wives separately, and we join her in her life with her sister and her courtship, marriage and family with Johnny. Her innocence has a certain pathetic charm when she kisses a dying young man on the cheek and fears that she may have become pregnant. She is attracted to the handsome Johnny and haltingly, even comically they consummate their marriage. Consummate would be a foreign word to her, so let’s say they have sex.

Poverty and ignorance do not abate their passion but a society that espouses ignorance and suppression of all knowledge about sex, birth control or abortion and seems to keep it away completely from the working class as if it were the bubonic plague is hardly to be sought. Not to mention that it was illegal to provide birth control information in Canada at that time and for many decades afterwards.

Children arrive, alive and stillborn, the Irish immigrant Johnny loses his job as a stable worker for a hotel, more pregnancies, no information about birth control, lack of basic necessities such as food arrive. Isn’t life and love just wonderful?

The spirit of Alma never leaves Sophie. Alma was gutsy, smarter and fearless. She became pregnant and put an end to her pregnancy - and her life. Her ghost visits Sophie as if it were a reminder of the road not taken or the road available to Sophie. It is frightful proposition.

Moscovitch tells us in the program that the play is based partly on the book of letters received by British birth control advocate Dr. Marie Stopes (Dear Dr. Stopes: Sex in the 1920s). One hundred years later it is hard to imagine the conditions that prevailed then unless one glances at the life of the poor in most countries of the world not least of which are parts of some southern states of what has finally become Great America Again.
Lisa Repo-Martell and Rebecca Parent. Photo: Timothy Richard
From commentator to pathetic, ignorant and tragic woman, wife and mother Repo-Martell does a fine job and is well-contrasted with the self-assured Alma of Rebecca Parent. Flemming as the handsome, macho, ignorant man who faces social challenges beyond his comprehension and ability to control looks for means of survival and can find none.

In the end there is a resolution as Sophie emulates her sister. I will not spoil the plot for you.
The play makes its points but it does not flow particularly smoothly. The plot shows structural weaknesses as it lunges from one point to the next.

The production is done on a bare stage designed by Andrew Cull with a few props such as a table. The rest of the atmosphere is handled by the lighting design of Leigh Ann Vardy.

What a Young Wife Ought to Know was first produced in Halifax in January 2015 by the Halifax-based 2b Theatre Company. The production is directed ably by Christian Barry, the Artistic Co-Director of 2b Theatre Company. It is theatre to see.
________________
What a Young Wife Ought to Know by Hannah Moscovitch continues until April 7, 2018 at the Streetcar Crowsnest Theatre, 345 Carlaw Avenue, Toronto, Ontario M4M 2T1. http://crowstheatre.com/ or http://www.2btheatre.com/

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

SCAPIN THE SCHEMER (LES FOURBERIES DE SCAPIN) – REVIEW OF COMEDIE-FRANCAISE PRODUCTION FOR THE CINEMA


Reviewed by James Karas

La Comédie-Française has joined other theatre companies in transmitting performances either live or recorded to cinemas around the world. A pre-recorded performance of Molière’s Les Fourberies de Scapin translated as Scapin the Schemer was shown in Toronto on March 14, 2018.

Scapin is a farce and this production seemed to have many of the virtues to provide a laugh-filled couple of hours in the theatre. Unfortunately the performance falls flat evoking only nominal laughter in the cinema as well as the audience in the Salle Richelieu in Paris.
 First, the story. We are in Naples and Argante (Gilles David) and Géronte (Didier Sandre) are away on business but they are planning the marriages of their sons Octave and Léandre. In the meantime, Octave has fallen in love with the lovely but poor Hyacinthe and married her. Léandre has fallen madly in love with the gypsy Zerbinette. Both men have committed filial disobedience of the worst kind. They problem can only be solved by Léandre’s valet Scapin who is a trickster, a schemer, a liar and a man of infinite talents.

The plot is straight from New Comedy and we know that all will be resolved in a couple of hours and the young lovers will live happily ever after. The play has an interesting difference. In this case the parents are not obstacles to their sons’ choice of brides. They are simply unaware that Hyacinthe is in fact Géronte’s daughter and Zerbinette is Argante’s daughter and the fathers’ choices for their sons.

Scapin, played by Benjamin Lavernhe dominates the play. Lavernhe seems like a highly talented actor who can do physical and verbal comedy. Director Denis Podalydès with Lavernhe and the rest of the cast has decided that there is no such thing as too much of a good thing. There is and Podalydès milks many scenes for laughs long after they have ceased being funny.

Scapin extracts money from both fathers in order to fulfill the needs of their sons. He manages to put Géronte in sack and beat him quite severely. The scene goes on forever as Lavernhe gets a youngster from the audience to take a few whacks at Géronte. That does evoke laughter as does his invitation to the audience to chant “Géronte” in unison. It is going over the top for a laugh which should have been generated by the performance without audience involvement.
 
Sandre as Géronte and David as Argante do yeomen work as classic old and stingy fathers who are used, abused and duped by Scapin.   Gaël Kamilindi as Léandre and Julien Frison as Octave are typical young lovers, long on passion, promises and ardour.

Adeline d’Hemy as Zerbinette pretends to be a wild gypsy and she gyrates wildly almost to the point of breathlessness. Pauline Clément as Hyacinthe does a fine job as a woman who knows what she wants.

Podalydès and designer Éric Ruf have set the production in the port of Naples. We see some sails in the background but the foreground looks like an abandoned storage depot with scaffolding on the right and broken boards.

In the end, we got a production that had many of the right ingredients but it misfired. The program tells us that Scapin has been performed more than 1500 times by the Comédie-Française but there had not been a new production for twenty years. Denis Podalydès was invited to do a new production. The result is a disappointment.
____________

Scapin the Schemer (Les Fourberies de Scapin) by Moliere was transmitted from the Comédie-Française, Paris, France on March 14, 2018 at the Cineplex Cinema Yonge-Dundas, 10 Dundas St. East, Toronto. For more information: www.cineplex.com/events

Saturday, March 24, 2018

THE MONUMENT – REVIEW OF FACTORY THEATRE PRODUCTION


James Karas

The monument in the title of Colleen Wagner’s play refers to a memorial for women who have been tortured, raped and killed in war. The play deals with that unimaginable and absolute evil and its success can only be limited by the impossibility of any form of art to express the inexpressible.

The play opens with a young man named Stetko (Augusto Bitter) describing how he raped a young girl. He is bragging as much as he is describing it and he accompanies his tale with a demonic laugh. He has raped and killed 23 women and he is refusing to disclose where their bodies are buried.
 
Tamara Podemski and Augusto Bitter in The Monument. Photo: Joseph Michael
Stetko is convicted, his hands are tied behind his back and he is awaiting execution. Mejra (Tamara Podemski) appears. She takes on many guises. She is his executioner, confessor, avenger and a seeker of an explanation about the actions of this monster. In the ninety minutes that the play lasts, Stetko the monster will present other views of his actions. He had to do it because others were doing it; things like that happen in war; there is no justice in war.

His initial denial of any knowledge of what he had done wanes and he recollects very well the horrific acts that he committed. Bitter gives a superb performance as the perpetrator of absolute evil who is transformed or perhaps finds his humanity and asks for forgiveness.

Mejra is a victim of the tactic of rape as a weapon of war and she is furious and vengeful but at the same time she is looking for information, an explanation, something to make her understand such acts of evil. Some or perhaps all of these things. Podemski in her brilliant and powerful performance goes through several phases and becomes a torturer herself in her attempts to break down Stetko.

My initial reaction was that the play should have finished in a couple of minutes with Mejra tying one of the ropes hanging from the ceiling around Stetko’s neck and raising him from the ground slowly, very slowly, as far as she could and then letting him drop to his well-deserved death in indescribable torment.

The Monument was written in 1995 and its context seems to be the rape of mostly Muslim women by soldiers during the breakup of Yugoslavia. Director Jani Lauzon tells us in a program note that she re-imagined the play through the Canadian issue and inquiry into Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls. This adds confusion rather than clarity. There is no war in Canada and references to soldiers raping and murdering indigenous women and girls as a tactic in ethnic cleansing are misleading. The play stands on its own well enough and the audience can relate to whatever part of the world it may be aware of where there is internecine war and rape is used as a strategic tactic.

The red dresses hanging on the stage and the ill-conceived attempt to give the play a Canadian context do not detract from the power of the play but they do not add anything either.

Wagner is groping for shreds of humanity and the idea of reaching the heart of a monster and making him ask for forgiveness. A noble sentiment that I find unconvincing. You can find or make Stetkos fairly easily in any war. Just give the orders, directly or indirectly, and many young men will succumb to rape and murder for many reasons from following the example of others to being brutalized by war and doing acts that they would find otherwise unthinkable.

The ultimate monsters are people who never kill, never fire a gun and never rape anyone. They are the political and military leaders who decide on strategy and tactics and make soldiers become monsters. Can we send a Mejra to see, say, Radovan Karadžić or Ratko Mladic or any number of other genocidal beasts and determine if there is a grain of humanity in them to make them understand their actions.

This is a riveting play that leaves you furious at our inhumanity and more so at the lack of any solution despite Wagner’s fervent hopes.
    _____

The Monument by Colleen Wagner, directed by Jani Lauzon, runs until April 1, 2018 at the Factory Theatre, 125 Bathurst Street, Toronto, Ontario. www.factorytheatre.ca/

CHRISTOS ZIATAS’ IPHIGENIA READ AT THE GREEK COMMUNITY


James Karas

Portions of Christos Ziatas’ play were read at the Greek Community’s Plymankio Centre last Tuesday, March 20, 2018. The event was organized by Bill Fatsis in honour of Ziatas’ literary achievements and to introduce the community to Iphigenia.

Iphigenia is a dramatization of the myth of the sacrifice of Agamemnon’s daughter at Aulis in order to get favourable winds for the Greek forces to cross the Aegean Sea to avenge the abduction of Helen Queen of Sparta by the Trojan prince Paris.

As most of you will recall, troops from the Greek city-states were gathered at Aulis in Euboea under the leadership of Agamemnon and the seer Kalchas told them that the gods needed a sacrifice in order to provide fair winds.  Agamemnon created a ruse that Iphigenia was to come to Aulis to marry Achilles when in fact he intended to sacrifice her.

Well-known personalities from the Greek community read a large portion of the play in the well-attended function. Andonis Artemakis read the part of Odysseus, Tassos Michalopoulos was Agamemnon while Spyros Volonakis represented his brother Menelaus. George Zubulakis was the seer Kalchas while Kostas Klissouras read the part of the Elder and First Solier. Christina Houtri was Iphigenia and Konstantinos Bourikas read the part of Achilles. Stavroula Karnouskou read the part of the Voice of Casandra and Iphigenia’s companion.

Andreas Batakis doubled as the Narrator and the “common man” Thersitis.

The evening was hosted by Bill Fatsis who also participated in the production as the Second Soldier and read the choral poems.

Ziatas was born in the village of Chalara in the mountains of Kastoria and was taken to Romania while still in public school during the Civil War. He grew up there and attended the University of Bucharest where he studied literature. He came to Canada in 1975 and has lived here ever since. Except for visiting, he has never lived in Greece.

He refers to himself as the poet of overtime as a reflection of the 18 hours each day that he spends wrestling with words and writing. Since 1971 when he published his first volume of poetry he has produced some 40 books of poetry, plays and criticism.

Ziatas was given recognition and appreciation. What he needs and deserves is more readers to recognize and appreciate the results of his overtime wrestling with words, a match that never stops until the perfect word is found to describe the precise sentiment.