Tuesday, November 17, 2026

GOODNIGHT DESDEMONA (GOOD MORNING JULIET) – REVIEW OF 2026 CANADIAN STAGE PRODUCTION

Reviewed by James Karas

Ann-Marie MacDonald is a wildly imaginative playwright, a prolific writer and an immensely talented performer. Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet) premiered in 1988 and reviving it 38 years later was an inspired choice for Canadian Stage. It is playing at the St. Lawrence Centre in Toronto.

It is a brilliant play that gets a superb production starring the author and directed by Alisa Palmer. We all know who Desdemona and Juliet are but a quick read of Othello and Romeo and Juliet will add to your enjoyment of the production.

Goodnight Desdemona is acted by five actors who handle seventeen roles (if I counted them right) and they cover a lot of territory. MacDonald is the only one that plays a single role and that leaves sixteen parts for the rest of them. In other words, pay attention and you will enjoy terrific theatre.

MacDonald has a thesis. Romeo and Juliet and Othello are really comedies and and if Shakespeare had included a Fool in both plays, he could have avoided the tragic ends. That theory is put in the mind of Constance Ledbelly, an Assistant Professor at Queen’s University. It is the juiciest role in the play and it is played splendidly by MacDonald. Her boss, the odious Professor Claude Night is a jerk and belittles Constance. She escapes from Canadian Academe and she appears via a trashcan in Shakespeare’s England and the two works of the title of the play.

Praneet Akilla, Caroline Toal, Ann-Marie MacDonald, and 
Carolyn Taylor. Photos by Dahlia Katz.

Romeo and Juliet a comedy? Yes. You remember the scene where Romeo and Tybalt face each other, exchange insults and Tybalt kills Mercutio and then Romeo kills Tybalt. Why didn’t Romeo tell Tybalt that he is married to his cousin Juliet and since they are now related there is no need for a fight. Othello falling for Iago’s bullshit? No way if the play had a Fool. Who is the author? Why are these good comedies turned needlessly into tragedies.

MacDonald re-enacts scenes from both plays to prove her point. The play opens in Constance’s office at Queen’s and after she spends time in Shakespeare’s England she returns to her office as do all the actors who played the various roles. Pay attention to her hat and the pen in her hair. The play opens with a poem about alchemy, and the search for the philosopher’s stone that turns base metal into gold. Look at the pen in her hair at the end. 

I cannot give many details about the brilliant twists and turns of the play. There is humour, drama, fascinating arguments, magic and sheer theatricality. 

Praneet Akilla, Caroline Toal, Ann-Marie MacDonald, and Carolyn Taylor. Photos by Dahlia Katz.

Praneet Akilla plays Romeo, Chorus, Iago and Ghost. One can appreciate the range between the passionate Romeo and the evil Iago as well as the relatively minor roles that Akilla has to handle and he does so with aplomb and expertise.

Stratford veteran and stalwart Jessica H. Hill handles Desdemona and Mercutio as well as the lesser roles of the non-Shakespearean student Ramona and the Servant. An expert at work.

Caroline Toal plays plays Juliet, balcony and suicide scenes included. As well as a Student and a Soldier of Cyprus. Her Juliet is splendid, but her death could be avoided if only the play had  a Fool.

Carolyn Taylor plays Professor Night who scuzzes Constance, Othello who is so dumb he falls for Iago’s bullshit, the irascible Tybalt and Juliet’s Nurse. She gets the major male roles who are ridiculous, of course, and gives them full-blooded performances.

The Set and Costume Design by Judith Bowden involve sets that go from an academic office to scenes from Shakespeare. I will just say that she has a huge job that she does  well and gives splendid results.

MacDonald’s wife Alisa Palmer directs the sprawling play with a sure and expert hand. The numerous scenes and changes in character by the actors are all done seamlessly and superbly.

The play can be enjoyed for its intelligence, variety, humour and theatricality. You can also dig more deeply into its complexity, its magic, its rich language, its feminist voice and its wild, imaginative trip into two of Shakespeare’s plays.

Go see it.

______________________

Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet) by Ann-Marie MacDonald will run until November 22, 2026, at the Bluma Appel Theatre, St. Lawrence Centre for the Arts, 27 Front Street East, Toronto, Ontario. www.canstage.com

 James Karas is the Culture Editor of The Greek Press, Toronto



No comments:

Post a Comment